- A-Frame Bookshelf
- AJPW Birthday Items
- AJ Backpack
- Alpha Armor
- Alpha Throne
- Ancient Dragon Set
- Animal Jam Box Items
- Arabian Den Item Set
- Arabian Horse Treasure Hunt
- Arabian Knight Set
- Arctic Fox Treasure Hunt
- Arctic Wolf Treasure Hunt
- Atlantis Set
- Autumn Fairy Set
- Ballet Set
- Balloon Column
- Bat Balloon
- Bean Bag Chair
- Beard
- Beetle Set
- Black Flame Crown
- Blackout Spiked Collar
- Bunny Ears
- Bunny Treasure Hunt
- Butterfly Glasses
- Butterfly Wings
- Camel Treasure Hunt
- Cami’s Frog Variants
- Campfire
- Candle
- Cat Ushanka Hat
- Charm Bracelet
- Charm Necklace
- Cheetah Treasure Hunt
- Circling Phantoms
- Comfortable Chair
- Conch Shell Set
- Confetti Archway
- Cougar Treasure Hunt
- Coyote Treasure Hunt
- Crocodile Treasure Hunt
- Cryo Set
- Crystal Den Collection
- Crystal Pegasus Collection
- Cupcake Hut
- Cupid Collection
- Curved Sofa
- Dapper Polar Set
- Daredevil Set
- Dark Set
- Decorative Vase
- Deer Treasure Hunt
- Designer Collection
- Dino Bonnet
- Direwolf Treasure Hunt
- Discontinued Bone Tail
- Discontinued Candy Corn Fangs
- Discontinued Clover Skirts
- Discontinued Cool Hair
- Discontinued Diner Booth
- Discontinued Jack-O-Lantern Hat
- Discontinued Magma Lamps
- Discontinued Plushies
- Discontinued Snowflake Boots
- Discontinued Square Glasses
- Discontinued Striped Vases
- Discontinued Three Horned Set
- Discontinued Tiny Shop Items
- Discontinued Treasure Hunt Items
- Discontinued and/or Unavailable Pets
- Dizzy Stars
- Double Tail
- Dragon Flower Set
- Dragonfly Wings
- Dual Samurai Swords
- Eagle Treasure Hunt
- Eclipse Set Clothing Items
- Eco Plaques
- Eco Solar Panel
- Eco Wind Turbine
- Elemental Set
- Elf Tail Armor
- Empress Set
- Epic Swan Wings
- Escaped Phantom Plushie
- Exclusive Plushies
- Exotic Pets & DNA Vials
- Faerie Wings
- Falcon Treasure Hunt
- Fancy Top Hat
- Fang Necklace
- Fantasy Chair
- Feathered Ears
- Feathered Set
- Fennec Fox Treasure Hunt
- Ferocious Feline Set
- Fez
- Fiddler Crab Collection
- Firefly Necklace
- Firefly Set
- Flamingo Treasure Hunt
- Flower Antlers
- Flower Beard
- Flower Crown
- Flower Petal Collar
- Founder Item Set
- Fox Tail Hat
- Fox Treasure Hunt
- Freedom Collection
- Galaxy Wings
- Giant Hedgehog Plushie
- Giant Phantom Plushie
- Gingerbread Wings
- Giraffe Treasure Hunt
- Glass Shelves
- Glow In The Dark Pet Condo
- Goat Treasure Hunt
- Golden Highland Pony Statue
- Golden Squirrel Statue
- Gorilla Treasure Hunt
- Grass Collection
- Grizzly Bear Treasure Hunt
- Hanging Snowy Lantern
- Heart Firefly Friend
- Heart Firework
- Hero Set
- Himalayan Tahr Treasure Hunt
- Home Theater
- Homemade Robot Costume Set
- Homemade Wings
- Horse Treasure Hunt
- Hyena Treasure Hunt
- Ice Pop Stand
- Icicle Antlers
- Ili Pika Treasure Hunt
- Jamaaliday Gift
- Jamaaliday Gift Calendar
- Jamaaliday Unicorn Horn
- Jamaaliday Wings
- Juice Fountain
- Jukebox
- King’s Armor Set
- Knight Helmet
- Koala Treasure Hunt
- Komodo Dragon Treasure Hunt
- Ladybug Bean Bag
- Ladybug Collection
- Lawn Chair
- Lawn Sprinkler
- Leafy Grass Rug
- Leap Year Frog Collection
- Leilani's Items
- Lemur Treasure Hunt
- Level Up Rewards
- Lightning Cape
- Lion Treasure Hunt
- Llama Treasure Hunt
- Long Striped Scarf
- Lovely Flowers
- Lynx Treasure Hunt
- Magenta Giant Jamaaliday Bow
- Magenta Tiara
- Magma Set
- Maned Wolf Treasure Hunt
- MasterBlock Trading
- Masterpiece Trading
- Max Leveled Prize Pals Rewards
- Meagyn's Pet Bear
- Meerkat Treasure Hunt
- Millionaire Plaque
- Mira Balloon
- Mira Fountain
- Modern Couch
- Monkey Treasure Hunt
- Moose Treasure Hunt
- Mushroom Collection
- Mystical Set
- Mystical Spiked Collar
- Natural Hot Spring
- New Year’s Party Hat
- New Year’s Star Balloon
- Nutcracker Set
- Ostrich Treasure Hunt
- Otter Treasure Hunt
- Outback Set
- Owl Treasure Hunt
- Pack Gifts
- Pack Run Spiked Collars
- Painter's Palette
- Paintseed Sapling
- Panda Backpack
- Panda Treasure Hunt
- Penguin Treasure Hunt
- Perfect Attendance Trophies
- Pet Backpack
- Pet Ducky
- Pet Fennec Fox
- Pet Honey Badger
- Pet Peacock
- Pet Pekin Rooster
- Pet Sugar Glider
- Pet Swan
- Pet Tarantula
- Phantom Flight Set
- Pigtail Hairdo
- Pillow Pets
- Pixelated Den Item Set
- Pixelated Heads
- Plaques
- Play Wild Item Worth Wiki
- Polar Bear Treasure Hunt
- Polar Set
- Postmaster Hat
- Potions
- Propeller Helmet
- Pumpkin Helmet and Armor
- Python Treasure Hunt
- Raccoon Treasure Hunt
- Rainbow Armor Set
- Rainbow Spiked Collar
- Rare 3D Glasses
- Rare Airplane Collection
- Rare Angry Jack-O-Lantern Mask
- Rare Archer Hat
- Rare Armadillo Set
- Rare Army Helmet
- Rare Art Easel
- Rare Aviator Hat
- Rare Baby Bonnet
- Rare Backpack
- Rare Bear Hat
- Rare Beehive Hairdo
- Rare Big Clown Lips
- Rare Bowtie
- Rare Brain Helmet
- Rare Bread Hat
- Rare Bubble Helmet
- Rare Butterfly Painting
- Rare Camouflage Boots
- Rare Candy Necklace
- Rare Cartoon Gloves
- Rare Cleverclaw’s Dresser
- Rare Clover Ring
- Rare Clown Hair
- Rare Coffin Table
- Rare Cone Collar
- Rare Construction Hat
- Rare Cool Shoes
- Rare Cornucopia Hat
- Rare Cotton Candy Shoes
- Rare Cowboy Boots
- Rare Crossbow
- Rare Curly Antlers
- Rare DJ Headset
- Rare Daisy Hat
- Rare Dino Horn
- Rare Doctor’s Bag
- Rare Dragon Wings
- Rare Eclipse Clothing Items
- Rare Egg
- Rare Elf Slippers
- Rare Explorer Compass
- Rare Explorer Goggles
- Rare Explorer Helmet
- Rare Explorer Radar Pack
- Rare Explorer Satchel
- Rare Fancy Shoes
- Rare Farm Sink
- Rare Farm Sprinkler
- Rare Feather Collection
- Rare Firefly Friend
- Rare Flapper Hat
- Rare Flower Antennae Headband
- Rare Flower Clothing Set
- Rare Flowered Arm Cuffs
- Rare Football Helmet
- Rare Forest Set
- Rare Frying Pan Hat
- Rare Full Moon Window
- Rare Furry Arm Cuffs
- Rare Geta Shoes
- Rare Gift Top Hat
- Rare Googly Eye Glasses
- Rare Halo
- Rare Head Bandage
- Rare Head Flower
- Rare Heart Antennae Headband
- Rare Heart Locket
- Rare Holly Bow
- Rare Horned Pilot Hat
- Rare Ice Cream Cone Helmet
- Rare Icicle Earrings
- Rare Item Mondays
- Rare Jamaaliday Bow
- Rare Jolly Elf Hat
- Rare Koi Pond
- Rare Lasso
- Rare Leg Armor
- Rare Lei
- Rare Lollipop Antlers
- Rare Meagyn's Pet Collection
- Rare Modern Shelves
- Rare Monocle
- Rare Moustache & Chops
- Rare Mystical Fairy Amulet
- Rare Offset Shelves
- Rare Old Hood
- Rare Ornament Earrings
- Rare Pet Clothing
- Rare Phantom Necklace
- Rare Pool Table
- Rare Potted Flower Hat
- Rare Raccoon Tail
- Rare Rainbow Hat
- Rare Royal Tiara
- Rare Rubber Boots
- Rare Saxophone
- Rare Scared Jack-O-Lantern Mask
- Rare Shooting Star Table
- Rare Skunk Hairdo
- Rare Snail Family Hat
- Rare Snow Shoes
- Rare Snowflake Balloon
- Rare Snowflake Headband
- Rare Snowy Top Hat
- Rare Spider Web Den Collection
- Rare Spooky Candy
- Rare Spooky Rug
- Rare Spooky Window
- Rare Spring Flower Horns
- Rare Star End Table
- Rare Steel Toe Boots
- Rare Stone Glove
- Rare Submarine Hat
- Rare Sun Hat
- Rare Sun Visor
- Rare Swiss Cheese Rug
- Rare Tablet
- Rare Tiki Table
- Rare Tulip Sun Visor
- Rare Umbrella Hat
- Rare Vanity Mirror
- Rare Wind-Up Key
- Rare Wooden Chest
- Rare Wooden Shoes
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.